Information Dynamics and the Perception of Temporal Structure in Music
Description
It has often been observed that one of the more salient effects of listening to music to create expectations within the listener, and that part of the art of making music to create a dynamic interplay of uncertainty, expectation, fulfilment and surprise. It was not until the publication of Shannon's work on information theory, however, that the tools became available to quantify some of these concepts. Since then, there has been sporadic interest in the relationship between information theory and music and aesthetic perception in general.
In this talk, we will examine how a small number of \emph{time-varying} information measures, such as entropies and mutual informations, computed in the context of a dynamically evolving probabilistic model, can be used to characterise the temporal structue of a stimulus sequence, considered as a random process from the point of view of a Bayesian observer.
One such measure is a novel \emph{predictive information rate} which we conjecture may provide an explanation for the `inverted-U' relationship often found between simple measures of randomness (\eg entropy rate) and judgements of aesthetic value (Berlyne 1971). We explore these ideas in the context of Markov chains using both artificially generated sequences and two pieces of minimalist music by Philip Glass, showing that even an overly simple model (the Markov chain), when interpreted according to information dynamic principles, produces a structural analysis which largely agrees with that of an expert human listener.
We will also discuss how the same principles can be applied to models more complex than the fully observed Markov chain (in particular, hidden Markov models), by using online variational Bayesian methods to track the observer's (probabilistic) beliefs about unobserved variables.
| Slides | |
| 0:00 | Information Dynamics and Temporal Structure in Music |
| 0:15 | Outline |
| 1:50 | - Expectation and surprise in music |
| 1:51 | Expectation and surprise in music |
| 2:57 | ‘Unfoldingness’ - 1 |
| 3:16 | ‘Unfoldingness’ - 2 |
| 3:20 | ‘Unfoldingness’ - 3 |
| 3:22 | ‘Unfoldingness’ - 4 |
| 3:24 | ‘Unfoldingness’ - 3 |
| 3:27 | ‘Unfoldingness’ - 4 |
| 3:40 | ‘Unfoldingness’ - 5 |
| 4:12 | ‘Unfoldingness’ - 6 |
| 6:24 | Probabilistic reasoning - 1 |
| 7:26 | Probabilistic reasoning - 2 |
| 8:48 | Probabilistic reasoning - 3 |
| 8:52 | Music and information theory - 1 |
| 10:48 | Music and information theory - 2 |
| 10:52 | Music and information theory - 3 |
| 11:38 | Music and information theory - 4 |
| 12:34 | Probabilistic model-based observer hypothesis - 1 |
| 12:56 | Probabilistic model-based observer hypothesis - 2 |
| 13:14 | Probabilistic model-based observer hypothesis - 3 |
| 14:17 | Features of information dynamics - 1 |
| 15:09 | Features of information dynamics - 2 |
| 15:53 | Features of information dynamics - 3 |
| 16:54 | Features of information dynamics - 4 |
| 17:43 | Contour theories |
| 19:27 | - Probabilistic model-based observation of random processes |
| 19:30 | Information theory primer: Entropy |
| 20:06 | Information theory primer: Relative entropy |
| 21:06 | Information theory primer: Mutual information |
| 21:20 | Information theory primer: Relative entropy |
| 21:41 | Information theory primer: Mutual information |
| 22:08 | Information theory in sequences |
| 22:55 | Three-way information measures |
| 24:30 | ‘Surprise’ based quantities - 1 |
| 24:53 | ‘Surprise’ based quantities - 2 |
| 25:25 | ‘Surprise’ based quantities - 3 |
| 26:32 | ‘Surprise’ based quantities - 4 |
| 26:48 | Predictive information |
| 27:29 | Predictive information based quantities - 1 |
| 28:00 | Predictive information based quantities - 2 |
| 28:22 | Predictive information based quantities - 3 |
| 28:39 | Predictive information based quantities - 4 |
| 28:53 | Information about model parameters - 1 |
| 29:20 | Information about model parameters - 2 |
| 29:22 | Complexity and aesthetics - 1 |
| 31:54 | Complexity and aesthetics - 2 |
| 31:56 | APIR as a measure of interestingness - 1 |
| 33:01 | APIR as a measure of interestingness - 2 |
| 33:03 | APIR as a measure of interestingness - 3 |
| 33:04 | APIR as a measure of interestingness - 4 |
| 33:31 | APIR as a measure of interestingness - 3 |
| 33:32 | APIR as a measure of interestingness - 2 |
| 33:33 | APIR as a measure of interestingness - 1 |
| 33:33 | APIR as a measure of interestingness - 2 |
| 33:34 | APIR as a measure of interestingness - 3 |
| 33:35 | APIR as a measure of interestingness - 4 |
| 33:37 | - Information dynamics in Markov chains |
| 34:12 | - Information dynamics in Markov chains |
| 34:23 | Markov chains: Definitions I |
| 35:11 | Markov chains: Definitions II |
| 35:33 | Information measures - 1 |
| 35:35 | Information measures - 2 |
| 36:10 | Entropy rate and APIR in Markov chains |
| 37:27 | Sequences with different APIR |
| 42:20 | Direct optimisation of APIR |
| 42:57 | - Related work |
| 42:58 | Bialek et al’s ‘Predictive information’ - 1 |
| 43:12 | Bialek et al’s ‘Predictive information’ - 2 |
| 43:52 | Bialek et al’s ‘Predictive information’ - 3 |
| 43:55 | Bialek et al’s ‘Predictive information’ - 4 |
| 44:04 | Dubnov’s ‘information rate’ - 1 |
| 44:38 | Dubnov’s ‘information rate’ - 2 |
| 45:28 | Other related work - 1 |
| 45:54 | Other related work - 2 |
| 45:58 | Other related work - 3 |
| 46:01 | - Experiments with minimalist music |
| 46:01 | Material and methods |
| 47:03 | Time-varying transition matrix model |
| 48:01 | Two Pages: Results |
| 50:06 | Two Pages: Discussion |
| 50:09 | Gradus: Results |
| 50:50 | Gradus: Discussion |
| 50:52 | - Info-dynamics in HMMs |
| 50:53 | Application to gesture recognition |
| 51:34 | HMM fitted to Wii data |
| 52:21 | Predictive information in HMM state sequence |
| 52:48 | Approximations for dealing with latent variables - 1 |
| 52:49 | Approximations for dealing with latent variables - 2 |
| 52:50 | Approximations for dealing with latent variables II - 1 |
| 52:51 | Approximations for dealing with latent variables II - 2 |
| 52:52 | Approximations for dealing with latent variables II - 3 |
| 52:53 | Approximations for dealing with latent variables II - 4 |
| 52:54 | - Summary and conclusions |
| 52:54 | Summary |
| 52:55 | Future work I |
| 52:55 | Future work II |
| 52:59 | Future work I |
| 53:24 | Future work II |
| 53:26 | - Questions |
Lecture rating
| People found this lecture: | ||
| Worth seeing | ||
| because it is: | ||
| Valuable and informative | ||
| Well presented | ||
| Easily understandable | ||
| Acceptably recorded | ||
| You need to login to cast your vote. | ||
Report a problem or upload files
If you have found a problem with this lecture or would like to send us extra material, articles, exercises, etc., please use our ticket system to describe your request and upload the data.Enter your e-mail into the 'Cc' field, and we will keep you updated with your request's status.
Related content
Link this page
Would you like to put a link to this lecture on your homepage?Go ahead! Copy the HTML snippet !





