event thumbnail image
European Conference on Complex Systems
Pascal

On the Relevance of Extremes vs. Means in Organization Science

author: Pierpaolo Andriani, Durham Business School, Durham University

Description

Scalability is a key element of complexity science. Many complex systems tend to be selfsimilar across levels—the same dynamics work at multiple levels. They are explained by scaling laws. Scalability results from what Mandelbrot calls fractal geometry. A cauliflower is an obvious example. Fractals often show Pareto distributions and are signified by power laws. Researchers find organization-related power laws in intrafirm decisions, consumer sales, salaries, size of firms, movie profits, director interlocks, biotech networks, and industrial districts, for example. Power laws signify Pareto distributions, which show “fat tails,” (nearly) infinite variance, unstable means, and unstable confidence intervals. Pareto distributions are alien to most quantitative organizational researchers, who are trained in Gaussian statistics and are trained to go to great lengths to configure their data to fit the requirements of linear regression, normal distributions, and related statistical methods. While normal distributions, and related current quantitative methods are still relevant for a significant portion of organizational research, power laws signify that Pareto distributions, fractals, and underlying scale-free theories are increasingly pervasive and valid characterizations of organizational dynamics. Where true, researchers ignoring power law effects risk drawing false conclusions and promulgating useless advice to practitioners. This because what is important to most managers are the extremes they face, not the averages. The implications for organization science, however, go beyond extreme events. Tools do not exist in a theoretical vacuum. The adoption of normal distribution statistics carries a heavy baggage of assumptions. Reliance on linearity, randomness, gradualism, and equilibrium influences how theories are built, how legitimacy is conferred, and how research questions are formulated. We begin with findings about 80 kinds of power laws. Then, we present sixteen scale-free theories that apply to organizations. Next, we discuss research implications. Then, we discuss implications in terms of the basic predictor function, y = f(x) + ε. How does basic thinking about prediction, data, statistics, and the error term have to change?

You might be experiencing some problems with Your Video player.
Slides
0:00 Scale-free theories in Org Science
2:15 36 Kinds of “Physical” Power Laws - part 1
2:20 36 Kinds of “Physical” Power Laws - part 2
2:23 Why do power law matter? Tail of extreme events
2:25 Evidence from financial markets
2:26 Rationality, stock market and the butterfly effect - part 1
2:28 Rationality, stock market and the butterfly effect - part 2
2:42 Rationality, stock market and the butterfly effect - part 3
2:43 Rationality, stock market and the butterfly effect - part 4
2:53 Rationality, stock market and the butterfly effect - part 5
3:03 Rationality, stock market and the butterfly effect - part 6
3:04 Rationality, stock market and the butterfly effect - part 7
3:20 Florence 1966
3:23 Dresden 2002
3:28 New Orleans 2006
3:31 Long Tails of Heterogeneous Niches - The impact of the Internet on the structure of markets
4:11 Kevin Laws: the biggest money in the smallest sales - part 1
4:29 Kevin Laws: the biggest money in the smallest sales - part 2
4:49 Kevin Laws: the biggest money in the smallest sales - part 3
5:28 Long Tails vs. AveragesandInterdependence vs. Independence - Which statistics?
5:36 Do It Yourself (Financial DIY)
6:07 Probability of financial crushes according to standard financial theory (Mandelbrot, 2004) - part 1
7:02 Probability of financial crushes according to standard financial theory (Mandelbrot, 2004) - part 2
7:23 Principles Underlying Power Law Statistics - part 1
8:09 Principles Underlying Power Law Statistics - part 2
8:32 Which approach to statistics?
9:10 Pluralism in power law causal mechanisms - Scale-free Theories Classification
9:46 Growth-related power laws -ratio imbalances
12:34 Combinations
14:39 Positive feedback loops
15:17 Contextual effects
15:50 Others –difficult to classify
16:18 Pluralism in the power law world - From Gaussian to Paretian
17:23 Italian Income Distribution
18:23 From independence to interdependence
20:22 Italian Income Distribution
21:06 The anti-power law 'camp‘
22:17 The danger of averages
22:46 What's Wrong?

Lecture rating

People found this lecture:
Worth seeing
because it is:
 Valuable and informative
Well presented
Easily understandable
Acceptably recorded
You need to login to cast your vote.

Report a problem or upload files

If you have found a problem with this lecture or would like to send us extra material, articles, exercises, etc., please use our ticket system to describe your request and upload the data.
Enter your e-mail into the 'Cc' field, and we will keep you updated with your request's status.

Link this page

Would you like to put a link to this lecture on your homepage?
Go ahead! Copy the HTML snippet !

Write your own review or comment: